It covers;
- the symptoms you might experience from a blocked EGR valve,
- the benefits of bypassing the E46 EGR valve,
- and how to actually bypass it.
(BMW OEM EGR valve part numbers: 11714701242, or 11717785452 from 2006 on wards).
Purpose of an EGR Valve
Exhaust Gas Re-circulation (EGR) valves are used in petrol and diesel engines as a method for reducing Nitrogen Oxide (NO) emissions.
EGR valves work by taking some of the exhaust gases and routing them back into the intake manifold. These gases reduce the peak combustion temperature in the cylinder, which in turn reduces the amount of NO produced by the combustion cycle.
Symptoms of a Blocked EGR Valve
Symptoms of a blocked of faulty EGR Valve can be: poor or decreased MPG, increased smoke or soot from the exhaust, increased harmful emissions, poor throttle response, engine running rough or lumpy, car feels down on power or torque and in extreme cases the vehicle is stalling at low speed.
There could be a number of causes for the above, but it's relatively simple to rule out the EGR value first. To see how your car compares to mine for fuel consumption, check out my post on real world 330d fuel economy. You might also want to clean you mass air flow (MAF) sensor.
Whilst I was carrying out the faulty thermostat replacement, I noticed that the EGR valve had started to coke up pretty heavily, again... Considering the time and mileage since I had last cleaned it, I was quite surprised, and concerned.
Just to show how quickly the carbon build up forms in the EGR valve, here is a photo from my DIY EGR valve carbon clean post, showing the valve freshly cleaned.
Now here's two more photos just 2 months later, after around 2000 miles.
As you can see, it's already looking worse for wear.
Location of the E46 EGR Valve
The E46 EGR valve is located at the front of the engine, underneath the plastic engine covers. The re-circulation pipe runs from the right hand side of the engine to the left where it joins to the EGR valve.
How to Bypass the E46 EGR Valve
-----
Unlike the earlier M47 and M57, those with the later M47N and M57N engines may get a warning light on the dash by disconnecting the EGR valve.
If you choose to do this bypass on your car, you do so at your own risk, I will accept no responsibility for any damage caused.
That's the disclaimer dealt with, on with the show.
-----
Fortunately, it's dead easy to bypass the EGR valve, as I will now explain.
Remove the engine plastics until the EGR valve is revealed, then locate the small vacuum pipe (black with a blue stripe) on the left hand side of the EGR and pull it off.
I then rummaged through a tin of assorted bolts and set screws until I found one about the right size to plug up the vacuum pipe I'd just removed. I used a bolt so that I could cut the thread off and just use the smooth shank (to avoid splitting the pipe).
Next I found something to cover up the tube on the EGR valve. For this I used a bit of silicone hose that was a real tight fit. Then plugged it with another bolt cut down.
With everything now plugged, I took the EGR valve off and gave it another clean in a bath of petrol. It's a messy job but the results were good.
Finally, I refitted the EGR valve, ensured both plugs were in tight, then cable tied the two together so that neither flapped around, and so they could easily be located if I wanted to re-enable the EGR valve.
So far I've noticed no adverse affects, only positive ones. The car seems to rev more freely and pulls slightly better. I will update in a few months if there are any developments.
E46 EGR Valve Blanking Kits
A kind of half way house between bypassing and deleting, is an EGR blanking kit*. Everything else remains connected, you just install a blanking plate at the exhaust end of the EGR pipe to prevent any gasses flowing through it. It's still a relatively inexpensive solution too, click the previous link or the image below to buy one on Amazon.
E46 EGR Valve Delete Kits
And finally, if you want to go one stage further than bypassing or blanking the EGR valve, you can purchase an EGR valve delete kit. Searching the phrase "E46 EGR valve delete" on eBay will return umpteen listings to choose from.
A seller on eBay called egr-delete appears to have a bit of a monopoly on the EGR delete kit market, offering kits for a variety of vehicles. The kits, like the one below, consist of a blanking kit and replacement pipe section.
Once fitted, the kit will completely remove the EGR system, providing an unrestricted airflow into the intake manifold.
The only downsides being it takes a bit of time to fit and costs a fair bit more than my method of just bypassing.
-----
Update: After several thousand miles and over two years of being bypassed, I've seen absolutely no adverse affects. All MOTs have been passed without issue, and with no increase in emissions.
-----
Let me know in the comments below if you've noticed the benefits of bypassing the EGR, or did you go all in and delete it? Has anyone had a problem come MOT time?
Make sure to subscribe using the Follow by Email widget in the top right for plenty more content to come!
You can also follow me on Facebook, Instagram and YouTube, search andybuck123.
25 Comments
And? Any news? Smoke free?
ReplyDeleteI have the same problem with my 330D and want to know if this solves the smoke permanent?
Hi there,
DeleteI don't have any black smoke at all under acceleration. I haven't checked the EGR recently for soot build up so I can't comment on that.
One thing I can comment on is that I have had no adverse effects on power or fuel consumption. The car also passed it's MOT with the EGR disconnected, so cannot have effected any of the readouts measured for that.
Another thing you could research is jet washing the inlet manifold, as these are notorious for being very sooty and gunked up, causing smoking. I believe mine is quite bad, but I haven't been in the position to look at this yet, if I do I will post my results.
Hope this helps,
Andy.
Hi there i have done what says but after a few days a got a error saying emisions limit is that cause of i have disconnected the egr vaccum pipe
ReplyDeleteThanks
Hi there,
DeleteI believe I read somewhere that M57N engines flag up an error when you disconnect the EGR valve, mine is an M57 type engine. I would recommend reconnecting it and seeing if the warning goes away.
I do not believe it should cause any serious problems from being disconnected, however, I would seek advice on your specific issue via a BMW forum (such as bimmerforums.co.uk).
Commenting from my experience, I have not received any errors at all following this modification. I have also read numerous accounts of people doing this modification with no error and for several years. I can only assume it is a M57N engine specific problem, or a completely unrelated issue.
Hope this helps,
Andy.
Hello thanks for your advice
DeleteI have a bmw e46 320 d from 1999
What you think about the warning Light?
It Will apear?
Thanks for your atention
Best regards
Hi, so when mounting the valve it is on the closed position?
ReplyDeleteCheers
Hi there,
DeleteThe removal of the vacuum hose (the one that has the bolts in it) means that the valve is shut permanently, stopping the exhaust gases from clogging it up. So yes, when the engine is not running or when replacing the EGR valve it will be in the closed position.
Regards,
Andy.
Its been a while since you did the EGR valve...is it still bypassed?
ReplyDeleteThanks
Brad
Hi Brad,
DeleteYes, over two years now looking at the post date. Absolutely no issues as a result.
I must admit I haven't taken it off to see if it has coked back up again though.
It has passed at least two MOTs in this condition, I believe the emissions actually improved after having done this.
Hope this helps,
Best regards,
Andy.
Many thanks Andy...when are you going to get some more posts on here?
ReplyDeleteread all you've posted with interest, I have 2003 330d with 126,000 miles.
Have you thought about doing the De Cat mod on the front down pipe?
Cheers
Brad
Hopefully soon Brad, simply a case of getting time (rather busy of late!)
DeleteNot sure I know what the decat mod is for the down pipe, could you explain? When I replaced my down pipe I did use an Ecotune decat pipe, but I didn't mod it in any way.
Best regards,
Andy.
I think this is a better solution
ReplyDeletehttp://www.bimmerforums.co.uk/forum/f18/e46-320d-m47n-1600rpm-1800rpm-jerked-t190066/
Hi, i must be the only person who cant take the egr valve off my 330d, the metal part on the left seems stuck on to the valve, is there a trick?!
ReplyDeleteSorted it now :)
DeleteYes it's stuck just hit it with a piece of wood, easy.
DeleteAnd some wd40 it's a bonus..
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteHi best regards for all of you from heart.
ReplyDeleteMy bmw 318tds, 1995 year not to go over 140km/h, and has no power, slow start when push gas, but starting motor is just fine an ok (no black smoke, no any problems more)
Please halp!
Thanks a lot!
Hi there guys .
ReplyDeleteI got a UK E46 2004 diesel Automatic,
And l just bypassed my EGR blocking the pipes. The EGR itself was a mess totally blocked.
l cleaned it and after driving with egr off just for couple of hours the EML came in dashboard .
Any suggestions?
To remap the egr from ecu would cost at least £70-£90.
And l really want to remove the egr.
Sorry forgot to mention its 320D.Engine code M47d2o01.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteJust followed the above procedure on my 2002 330d sport m57, it was hunting previously. It is much smoother at tickover now and when moving slowly. It revs more freely from low revs as well. I still have smoke out the back on full throttle kickdown beyond 4000 rpm. May be due to my car having been mapped? A useful mod. Thanks for the blog.
ReplyDeleteAwesome, glad it helped and thanks for taking the time to leave a comment!
DeleteHi Andy so what in your opinion is the benefit of doing the blanking and or delete vs just doing the bypass by blocking the vacuum pipes?
ReplyDeleteThanks in advance
Hi there,
DeleteIn my opinion, I don't see any value in blanking over just disconnecting the vacuum pipe. Blanking takes more effort, adds no benefit above just disconnecting the vacuum pipe (other than a tiny weight reduction of deleting the EGR pipe), costs more and isn't as quick to reverse. If for whatever reason you had a problem at the MOT, having just disconnected the vacuum pipe, you could quickly and easily reconnect it and re-run the MOT.
If you want to do a 'proper job' of it, perhaps for a track car build, you need to do the full EGR delete, where you replace the EGR valve for a straight pipe and delete the EGR pipe as well. This gives you improved, unrestricted air flow into the intake manifold, a small weight saving by removing the EGR valve and diaphragm, and removing the EGR pipe. Clearly though this costs more and takes a bit longer to do.
Hope this helps :)
Cheers,
Andy.
Thanks Andy much appreciated
ReplyDeletePost a Comment
Let me know what you think by leaving a comment below.